Search This Blog

Friday, July 4, 2008

Post #9 "Dry Drowning": How Worried Should You Really Be?

On June 1, 2008 10-year old Johnny Jackson got water in his lungs while swimming in the pool. He walked home, took a bath, and went to bed; he died in his sleep during a nap an hour later. The county coroner reported water in the boy's lungs.

On June 5, 2008 todayshow.com reported the following:

"According to the Centers for Disease Control, some 3,600 people drowned in 2005, the most recent year for which there are statistics. Some 10 to 15 percent of those deaths was classified as “dry drowning,” which can occur up to 24 hours after a small amount of water gets into the lungs. In children, that can happen during a bath."

While the 3,600 number is fairly accurate (3,582 to be exact), the 10-15% statistic is erroneous and the CDC enterprise communication officer Sandy Bonzo has since issued a statement as such. There are no statistics on the percentage of "dry drownings".

Soon after Johnny's unfortunate drowning, there was a full-on media blitz with the Today Show spearheading the charge. The media did what the media does best: it struck the "Moms you had better take note for your chid's sake or else suffer the consequences" nerve. What followed was a slew of stories on multiple websites, newspapers and local news channels on "dry drowning". . . the story at 10 and you had better not miss it if you care about your child. . .

Although the phrase "dry drowning" is an ideal term for a newscaster hoping to invoke fear in the heart of the average mother, it is a somewhat misleading phrase. In fact, there are so many different phrases used to describe drowning (such as wet drowning, dry drowning, near drowning, secondary drowning, passive drowning) that it leads to ambiguity in what physiologically has actually occurred in each individual case. In an attempt to simplify matters, the 2002 World Congress on Drowning held in Amsterdam defined drowning as the process of experiencing respiratory impairment from submersion/immersion in liquid.

So what do people mean by "dry drowning" then?

It's hard to pinpoint exactly as there is no set definition, but it seems to be any situation where a person cannot breathe and water does NOT enter the lungs. In this sense "dry drowning" could conceivably apply to laryngospasms (spasms of your windpipe) and such external causes such as a lung puncture or a heavier-than-air gas filling the lungs. Even in an underwater drowning, it is conceivable that a person could suffer laryngospasms and die from oxygen deprivation without water entering the lungs, and hence be classified as a dry drowning when in fact the person was fully submerged underwater. You can see how there is ambiguity and confusion in using these terms, which is why the 2002 Congress uses one universal definition.

So exactly what happened in Johnny's case then?

Most likely Johnny did swallow some water while he played in the pool and some of the water made it into his lungs (which then technically is not a "dry drowning" even though the death occured out-of-water). This water then led to a loss of pulmonary function after the "loss or inactivation of surfactant" of the alveoli in the lungs. Surfactant is an amphiphilic compound which reduces the surface tension of your lungs allowing you to breathe. Basically, it helps your lungs to expand easily allowing oxygen to enter. The water that made it into Johnny's lung disrupted the ability of his natural surfactant and therefore as he napped, he was unable to breathe properly leading to his unfortunate demise.

This type of situation is uncommon, however there are no exact statistics on it. And although it can be a scary concept to every mother whose child goes swimming during the summertime and then on occasion takes a nap, things must be put into perspective.

First, most drownings do not occur this insidiously. Rather, the majority of drownings happen where it is clear that the child has been submerged under water. In this sense, things can be done to avoid the obvious drowning: close supervision, fences/covers/alarms around unused pools, CPR training, etc.

Second, even in a case such as Johnny's, there will be some warning signs: accidental ingestion of water, forceful coughing >1 minute right after coming out of the water, difficulty breathing, extreme fatigue and changes in behavior. If your child clearly is having an excessive amount of coughing and difficulty breathing right after swimming, it would be evident to the observant mother.

Finally, there is more risk in driving your child to the local movie theater than there is in monitored water play.

The bottom line is that like many other risks that the media has over-hyped, "dry drowning" is a real risk but a very unlikely one if you follow safe water practices. One good thing about this media blitz has been an increased awareness about general water safety, which only benefits summer activities. In this sense, hopefully Johnny's life will serve as a beacon to every mother and child swimming this summer.

5 comments:

Miranda Heart said...

I'm really glad that you posted this. As paranoid as I get about so many other things this is one thing I didn't want to be freaked out about. I saw and read the report on this and although in my heart I felt that if we pay attention to our children things like this are less likely to occur, it still raised the question of what if? What if I did everything and it still happened. I taught my daughter how to swim when she was 2 1/2. So you can only imagine the fear (someone who isn't necessarily qualified to teach swim lessons) that goes through someone's mind when they think of someone so tiny being in that kind of danger.

You're right about parental instinct. Second guessing it isn't a good idea, even if it isn't always right on the money.

Thanks again for relieving some of my fears.

Anonymous said...

I also am thankful for this activle, one of the only balanced article out there about this sad accident. I life guarded and taught lessons all thru college. I know have an inground pool, 4 kids and constant activity and friends over to swim. My 2 1/2 year old is also learning to swim. He wanted to learn, I haven't really pushed the idea. I would rather them have a little fear than none at all. I have a friend with a 3 year old who is always worried about something and is freaked out everytime her little one swallows even the littlest amount of water and coughs. I understand there are dangers but how many millions have gotten a little water and coughed and survived. Most everyone who has ever had a bath or played in the pool. Hopefully your blog will calm the hearts of many. Blessings

Paloma Green said...

Thank you so much for this i saw an article less than a month ago we just went swimming tonight wheni go with my 2 and a half year old I have top stay by him constantly bc he is a daredevil and it drives me crazy. Well he hasn't had a nap all day then we went swimming kind of late and he just goes to bed right after and while he's asleep he hada little cough just once but now here I am up and worried bc what if he got some water swallowed I'm scared half to death and all that's on Google is very scary stories. This article makes me feel a little better Thank you

Amanda taylor said...

This article has definitely eased my mind a bit and cleared up a lot of confusion. Knowing that it's a rare instance and that the signs will be almost immediately apparent helps me relax about it a bit. Definitely glad to be aware of this and know what to watch out for though. It also helped me stop panicking enough from the thought of the whole situation to stop and think about how many times myself and everyone I've ever known has swallowed or inhaled a pretty significant amount of water probably several times while horsing around in the pool, lake, and ocean and also diving into cold water (as most of us were told it was easiest to handle the cold water by doing it all at once) and not had anything like this happen to us as a result. To end a long comment (lol) this was very helpful. Thank you!!!

Anonymous said...

Thank you! Nine years later, your post still works to ease parents' troubled minds.